Last night we went for a VERY late dinner with the kids — after 9 pm — to a bar-type burger restaurant in Uptown. The restaurant has a gigantic photograph on the wall, a Chuck Close-style photograph of the head of an urban hipster having a gigantic juicy burger stuffed ironically into his gaping mouth, the lettuce and tomato dripping onto his ironically unshaven chin.
The kids had kid-sized cheeseburgers and fries and a shake and some onion rings. Mark, who enjoys a good burger sometimes, had a big bacon cheeseburger and a pint of local stout.
I asked if the veggie burger was made in-house and got a curt "No." Not about to shell out $8 for a veggie puck that had been shaken out of a box moments ago, I contemplated a big patty melt, since the last thing I had eaten was three slices of Hannah's homemade banana bread, six hours ago. My stomach was really growling.
But! I noticed they had sliders for $3 each, which I suspected (correctly) were the same as the kid-sized burgers. I ordered a big salad and one slider, with lettuce and tomato to drip onto my non-ironically unshaven chin. I ate the little burger first, so I could enjoy it while it was still hot and fresh and the edges of the bun still crisp, and at the end of it I wished there was a second one on my plate. But by the time I had gotten to the bottom of my salad, I felt comfortable.
I was glad I had not said to myself, "I'm truly hungry, so it's okay to have a full-size burger." Even though I surely could have eaten it and would have enjoyed every bite. The truth is, whenever I try to eat in response to my hunger, I fool myself into eating more than my hunger requires. Structure is more important.
I keep learning this over and over again: sometimes by making a mistake (eating too much and being overfull), and sometimes by not making a mistake (fixing less food than I think my hunger requires and discovering that it is indeed satisfying.)
I am less and less impressed by the idea that to lose or maintain weight, people should eat "when hungry and only when hungry." It's just too vague and easy to defeat in the face of the slightest desire to eat.