The power of routine, or, is it a good or bad idea to be flexible?

One thing I'm discovering is that I screw up — eat too much — far more easily when I'm deviating from my usual schedule.

I realize it very quickly these days.  Now that I'm out of "practice," I feel uncomfortably full just a few minutes after overdoing it.  

This happened to me today.  Usually, I have breakfast when I wake, lunch at 12:30, and dinner at 6 or 6:30; I usually don't eat solid food after dinner's over, except maybe a piece of chocolate.  On Thursdays, the kids have swimming lessons from 6 to 6:40, so that's our Family Gym Night.  On Thursdays we have dinner around 7:15.  I have a midafternoon snack, and I get dinner ready in advance so I don't nibble while preparing it, and usually there's no problem.

For a couple of reasons, tonight Mark and I decided I should feed the kids and myself an early dinner BEFORE meeting him at the gym for swimming.  I made scrambled eggs and ham and toast for them.  And I ate… OK, you're going to think this is weird, but I ate an entire package of Brussels sprouts.  So far so good, but then I went on and had some of the ham and eggs and  toast too, and also some leftover rice noodles, and … what was I thinking?  Right NOW I am thinking "ooooff I feel so full."  But what was going on with that?  

A mess of stuff.  I skipped the 3:30  snack because I was going to eat dinner at five or so, an hour early.  And then by the time 4:15 rolled around, I wasn't HUNGRY exactly, but I started to want to eat.  I was cold, for one thing.  I am cold all the time now, I guess for want of insulation.  And the thought of eating something hot started to consume me.  So I started cooking the Brussels sprouts.  And then the eggs.  And then the eggs were done before the sprouts.  And then the kids didn't finish the eggs.  And then they left a bunch of toast on their plates.  And I started thinking, "Gosh, if I don't eat extra now, I'll be pretty hungry later, seeing as how I never eat a bedtime snack anymore!"  (Mental note:  Beware, beware of the "I'd better eat more now so I'm not hungry later" line of thought.  It is evil.)  I don't know.  Somewhere in there came the thought that I should eat some chocolate to send a signal to myself that my dinner was done.  Somehow I decided I needed to send that signal a couple of times.   

I'm OK now.  I have a cup of coffee in front of me.  And I have to leave for swimming soon.  And I feel alarmingly full.  And I know, I just know, that I would not have done this — basically a binge, which is only sort of redeemed by the fact that it's mostly Brussels sprouts by weight — if I had planned on eating dinner after swimming as usual.

This all underscores to me that even though I am not overweight anymore, I still have a problem.  Euphemisms, sheesh.  I have an unhealthy attachment to food and to being unhungry.  I have developed a lot of coping strategies, and I can't let go of them, at least not yet.   One of those strategies is, more or less, a strict schedule for my meals and snacks.  I have seen that I change it at my peril.  

It comes on top of a recent conversation I had with Mark.  He thinks I should start being more flexible. Especially with regard to exercise.  I still refuse to miss a swimming workout.  I still swim every Monday and every Thursday.  When our pool was closed for repairs over the summer, I drove across town to another one, even if it seriously messed up our family's schedule.  I am already making plans to drive 20 minutes into town from my in-laws' so that I can swim at the Y near their house when we stay with them later.  He wants me to quit swimming so much and take up something more portable, like running, that I can do even if swimming becomes unworkable on a particular day.

He has a point.  I am not ready, though, to change my routines.  I lost the weight by doing what I have been doing.  I don't want to do something else.  Mark thinks it's time for me to move on.   He has been fantastically supportive, and has never complained about the stresses I put on our family with my workouts and the scheduling of meals — at least not until now.   I know from experience that I can change my routines, but I also know from experience that I have to change them slowly, experiment with them, see what works — not just jump from one to the other.  Safe "flexibility" is a carefully curated toolbox of strategies, each proven to work in different situations.  I have had time to develop only a few.  This is going to take me years.

I think he looks at me and sees someone who has solved her weight problem.  But I am me, and I know what I am, and I am not someone who has solved her weight problem.  I am a person who still lives with it, because my "problem" is the cause, not the symptom; the weight is gone, but I have the same biochemistry, the same psychology, I always have.  I am not stable here.  I am not robust.  I am a recovering obese person, and maybe always will be.   


Comments

3 responses to “The power of routine, or, is it a good or bad idea to be flexible?”

  1. As a similar-sized (now) to you person, I have spent a lot of time being cold. Invest in nice cardigans. ๐Ÿ™‚

    Like

  2. Hey Erin,
    Flexibility is great when can afford it. I think there will definitely be a time when you can. Now may not be that time though since you are in transition from losing to maintaining. One concern about flexibility is that it can cause a person to feel uncertain or even out of control especially when you are not really confident of your “regular” routine. It sounds like it may take a some time of maintaining before you feel really confident that you can stay at your goal weight despite minor fluctuations. I would encourage flexibility at that point (especially if it involves running and biking – hint, hint).
    Ah, just my two cents worth…take it for what it is. See you soon!!

    Like

  3. Christy P Avatar
    Christy P

    Wool socks. All the time.

    Like

Leave a reply to Kim Cancel reply